96 ꢁ (ꢂQ − ꢃ)
ꢅꢁꢀꢃꢂ32:(5ꢂ6833/<ꢂ$1'ꢂ3&%ꢂ/$<287
7KHꢀ GHYLꢅHꢀ UHTXLUHVꢀ Dꢀ VWDEOHꢎꢀ QRLVHꢄIUHHꢀ SRZHUꢀ VXSSO\ꢆꢀ $ꢀ ORZꢀ ꢅRVW
ꢃꢔ/ꢇꢐꢀꢅODVVꢀUHJXODWRUꢀZLOOꢀZRUNꢀILQHꢀIRUꢀYLUWXDOO\ꢀDOOꢀDSSOLꢅDWLRQVꢎꢀEXWꢀLW
VKRXOGꢀ QRWꢀ EHꢀ VKDUHGꢀ ZLWKꢀ GHYLꢅHVꢀ WKDWꢀ ꢅDQꢀ SURGXꢅHꢀ WUDQVLHQWVꢀ RU
HUUDWLꢅꢀ ORDGLQJꢆꢀ 'HVLJQVꢀ VKRXOGꢀ XVHꢀ Dꢀ UHJXODWRUꢀ VSHꢅLILꢅDOO\ꢀ IRUꢀ WKH
47ꢂꢃꢇꢁ%ꢉꢀ LIꢀ SRVVLEOHꢌꢀWHVWLQJꢀ ꢅDQꢀ GHWHUPLQHꢀ LIꢀWKHꢀ UHJXODWRUꢀ ꢅRXOG
EHꢀVKDUHGꢀZLWKꢀRWKHUꢀꢅLUꢅXLWU\ꢆ
ꢀ
ꢀꢀ 1 96 $9 ꢁ &7
&
7
ꢀꢀ 1 $9 (ꢂQ − ꢃ) ꢀꢀ^&[ꢀSHUꢀ$'&ꢀOHYHO`
*LYHQꢒ &Wꢀ ꢀꢇꢆꢇꢐꢏꢀ)ꢀꢗꢀꢍꢀ[ꢀꢇꢆꢇꢇꢍꢃꢀ)ꢀ ꢀꢇꢆꢇꢃꢍꢔꢀ)
1ꢀ ꢀꢏꢍꢎꢀ $Yꢀ ꢀꢉꢔꢍꢎꢀQꢀ ꢀꢔꢀELWV
7KHꢀꢃꢔ/ꢇꢐꢀVKRXOGꢀEHꢀSURSHUO\ꢀE\SDVVHGꢀRQꢀLWVꢀLQSXWꢀDQGꢀRXWSXWꢆꢀ,WV
LQSXWꢀVXSSO\ꢀVKRXOGꢀDOVRꢀEHꢀUHODWLYHO\ꢀVWDEOHꢀDQGꢀQRLVHꢄIUHHꢀVRꢀDVꢀWR
PLQLPL]Hꢀ IHHGWKURXJKꢀ QRLVHꢀ ꢅRPSRQHQWVꢀ YLDꢀ LWVꢀ SDVVꢀ WUDQVLVWRUꢆꢀ $
ꢉꢉ)ꢀ WDQWDOXPꢀ RUꢀ ꢁꢇꢇꢀ )ꢀ ORZꢄ=ꢀ DOXPLQXPꢀ ꢅDSDꢅLWRUꢀ LV
UHꢅRPPHQGHGꢀRQꢀWKHꢀRXWSXWꢀRIꢀWKHꢀꢃꢔ/ꢇꢐꢆ
7KHQꢀWKHꢀRYHUDOOꢀVHQVLWLYLW\ꢀLVꢀDERXWꢀꢁꢏꢀIHPWRIDUDGVꢀSHUꢀ$'&ꢀOHYHOꢆ
7KLVꢀꢅDQꢀHDVLO\ꢀEHꢀDGMXVWHGꢀE\ꢀDOWHULQJꢀDQ\ꢀRIꢀWKUHHꢀSDUDPHWHUVꢒꢀ1ꢎ
ZKLꢅKꢀꢅDQꢀEHꢀDOWHUHGꢀLQꢀWKHꢀHꢀSURPꢀVHWXSVꢎꢀDPSꢀJDLQꢀ$YꢎꢀDQGꢀWRWDO
VDPSOHUꢀꢅDSDꢅLWDQꢅHꢀ&Wꢆ
1RWHꢀWKDWꢀVXSSO\ꢀYROWDJHꢀ9VꢀꢅRQYHQLHQWO\ꢀGURSVꢀRXWꢀRIꢀWKHꢀHTXDWLRQꢀꢄ
WKXVꢎꢀ WKHꢀ VHQVRUꢀ LVꢀ ODUJHO\ꢀ LPPXQHꢀ WRꢀ VORZꢀ ꢅKDQJHVꢀ LQꢀ VXSSO\
YROWDJHꢎꢀDOWKRXJKꢀLWꢀꢅDQꢀEHꢀVHQVLWLYHꢀWRꢀWUDQVLHQWꢀVXSSO\ꢀH[ꢅXUVLRQV
ZKLꢅKꢀGRꢀQRWꢀHTXDOO\ꢀDIIHꢅWꢀDOOꢀDVSHꢅWVꢀRIꢀWKHꢀDꢅTXLVLWLRQꢀSURꢅHVVꢆ
$ꢀ3&%ꢀ JURXQGꢀSODQHꢀ RUꢀꢅRSSHUꢀ SRXUꢀDUHDꢀ WKURXJKRXWꢀWKHꢀ ꢅLUꢅXLWꢀLV
KLJKO\ꢀ UHꢅRPPHQGHGꢆꢀ 2WKHUꢀ ꢅLUꢅXLWVꢎꢀ LQꢅOXGLQJꢀ DQ\ꢀ RXWSXWꢀ GULYHU
WUDQVLVWRUVꢎꢀ VKRXOGꢀ QRWꢀ DOORZꢀ WKHLUꢀ ꢅXUUHQWVꢀ WRꢀ IORZꢀ WKURXJKꢀ WKH
VHQVRU¶Vꢀ ꢅLUꢅXLWꢀ DUHDꢌꢀ JURXQGVꢀ VKRXOGꢀ DOZD\Vꢀ EHꢀ OHGꢀ EDꢅNꢀ WRꢀ D
ꢅRPPRQꢀWLHꢀSRLQWꢀDWꢀWKHꢀSRLQWꢀQHDUꢀWKHꢀHQWU\ꢀRIꢀWKHꢀVXSSO\ꢀRQWRꢀWKH
3&%ꢀLQꢀDꢅꢅRUGDQꢅHꢀZLWKꢀꢅXVWRPDU\ꢀ³VHQVLWLYHꢀDQDORJ´ꢀSUDꢅWLꢅHꢆ
ꢅꢁꢀꢉꢂ%*ꢐꢂ%*ꢍ2%-ꢐꢂ$1'ꢂ2%-ꢂ02'(6
7KHꢀ47ꢂꢃꢇꢁ%ꢉꢀRSHUDWHVꢀLQꢀHLWKHUꢀRIꢀWZRꢀSULPDU\ꢀꢅDOLEUDWLRQꢀPRGHVꢒ
6HQVHꢀOHDGꢀꢅODPSꢀGLRGHVꢀVKRXOGꢀVKXQWꢀ(6'ꢀꢅXUUHQWVꢀEDꢅNꢀWRꢀHDUWK
YLDꢀWKHꢀPRVWꢀGLUHꢅWꢀURXWHꢀSRVVLEOHꢎꢀZLWKRXWꢀWUDYHUVLQJꢀWKHꢀDUHDꢀRIꢀWKH
ꢅLUꢅXLWU\ꢌꢀ (6'ꢀ UHWXUQꢀ ꢅXUUHQWVꢀ VKRXOGꢀ DOVRꢀ QRWꢀ VKDUHꢀ Dꢀ ꢅRPPRQ
JURXQGꢀ SDWKꢀ ZLWKꢀ WKHꢀ VHQVRUꢀ ꢅLUꢅXLWU\ꢆꢀ 7KHVHꢀ ꢅODPSꢀ GLRGHVꢀ VKRXOG
VKXQWꢀDVꢀGLUHꢅWO\ꢀWRꢀDꢀERDUGꢀPRXQWLQJꢀKROHꢀꢋRUꢀRWKHUꢀPDMRUꢀJURXQGꢀWLH
SRLQW-ꢀ DVꢀ SRVVLEOHꢆꢀ 3RVLWLYHꢀ ꢅODPSHGꢀ (6'ꢀ ꢅXUUHQWVꢀ DUHꢀ RIWHQ
QHJOHꢅWHGꢀLQꢀGHVLJQVꢌꢀWKH\ꢀVKRXOGꢀEHꢀVKXQWHGꢀYLDꢀDꢀKLJKꢀTXDOLW\ꢀORZ
LQGXꢅWDQꢅHꢀE\SDVVꢀꢅDSDꢅLWRUꢀDQGꢈRUꢀ]HQHUꢀEDꢅNꢀWRꢀWKHꢀVDPHꢀJURXQG
WLHꢀSRLQWꢆ
ꢁꢆ µ1RUPDO¶ꢀPRGHꢂꢀVHQVRUꢀPDNHVꢀXVHꢀRIꢀWKHꢀVHWWLQJꢀRIꢀ'HWHꢅW
7KUHVKROGꢆꢀ7KLVꢀPRGHꢀLVꢀWKHꢀIDꢅWRU\ꢀGHIDXOWꢀVHWWLQJꢆꢀ(YRNLQJꢀ%*
LQꢀµQRUPDO¶ꢀPRGHꢀVLPSO\ꢀꢅDXVHVꢀDꢀUHꢅDOLEUDWLRQꢀWRꢀRꢅꢅXUꢎꢀWKDWꢀLVꢎ
WKHꢀUHIHUHQꢅHꢀSRLQWꢀLVꢀUHꢅHQWHUHGꢀDQGꢀZLWKꢀLWꢀWKHꢀWKUHVKROG
OHYHOꢋV-ꢆꢀµ1RUPDO¶ꢀPRGHꢀLVꢀ%*ꢀPRGHꢀDQGꢀLVꢀUHIHUUHGꢀWRꢀDVꢀ%*
PRGHꢆ
ꢉꢆ µ/HDUQ¶ꢀPRGHꢂꢀ7KHꢀVHQVRUꢀLJQRUHVꢀ'HWHꢅWꢀ7KUHVKROGꢎꢀDQG
µOHDUQVꢀE\ꢀH[DPSOH¶ꢆꢀ7KHUHꢀDUHꢀWZRꢀYDULDWLRQVꢀRIꢀµ/HDUQ¶ꢀPRGHꢒ
%*ꢈ2%ꢕꢎꢀDQGꢀ2%ꢕꢆ
&RPSRQHQWꢀ ORꢅDWLRQꢀ LVꢀ UHODWLYHO\ꢀ XQLPSRUWDQWꢀ DQGꢀ QRQꢄꢅULWLꢅDOꢎꢀ ZLWK
WKHꢀ DERYHꢀ QRWHGꢀ H[ꢅHSWLRQVꢎꢀ DQGꢀ WKHꢀ ꢅLUꢅXLWꢀ ꢅDQꢀ HDVLO\ꢀ EH
LPSOHPHQWHGꢀRQꢀDꢀꢉꢄOD\HUꢀ3&%ꢆ
6ZLWꢄKLQJꢀPRGHVꢂꢀ7KHVHꢀPRGHVꢀꢅDQꢀEHꢀHQWHUHGꢀLQWRꢀDWꢀZLOOꢀE\ꢀWKH
XVHꢀRIꢀWKHꢀ%*ꢀDQGꢀ2%ꢕꢀꢅRQWUROꢀOLQHVꢀDVꢀH[SODLQHGꢀEHORZꢆ
ꢅꢁꢀꢅꢂ$1$/2*ꢂ287387ꢂ9,$ꢂ603ꢂ/,1(
0DNLQJꢀWKHꢀPRGHꢀSHUPDQHQWꢂꢀ 7KHꢀVHOHꢅWHGꢀ%*ꢎꢀ%*ꢈ2%ꢕꢀRUꢀ2%ꢕ
$Qꢀ DQDORJꢀ RXWSXWꢀ PD\ꢀ RSWLRQDOO\ꢀ EHꢀ REWDLQHGꢀ XVLQJꢀ Dꢀ VDPSOHꢀ DQG PRGHꢀ ꢅDQꢀ EHꢀ VWRUHGꢀ ³SHUPDQHQWO\´ꢀ LQWRꢀ WKHꢀ H[WHUQDOꢀ HꢀSURPꢀ LI
KROGꢀꢅLUꢅXLWꢆꢀ7KHꢀ47ꢂꢃꢇꢁ%ꢉꢀSURYLGHVꢀDꢀVDPSOHꢀSXOVHꢀꢋ603-ꢀZKLꢅK SUHVHQWꢎꢀ EXWꢀ RQO\ꢀ LIꢀ 'DWDꢀ /RꢅNLQJꢀ >)ꢆE@ꢀ LVꢀ RQꢆꢀ 7KHꢀ PRGHꢀ ꢅDQꢀ EH
LVꢀDꢀSRVLWLYHꢄGULYHꢀSXOVHꢀWLPHGꢀWRꢀꢅRLQꢅLGHꢀZLWKꢀDꢀVWDEOHꢀSRUWLRQꢀRIꢀWKH ꢅKDQJHGꢀ DWꢀ DQ\ꢀ WLPHꢀ DQGꢀ LVꢀ DXWRPDWLꢅDOO\ꢀ VWRUHGꢀ DJDLQꢀ LQWRꢀ WKH
RXWSXWꢀRIꢀWKHꢀVLJQDOꢀDPSOLILHUꢀꢅKDLQꢆ
HꢀSURPꢎꢀRYHUZULWLQJꢀWKHꢀSULRUꢀPRGHꢆꢀ,Iꢀ'DWDꢀ/RꢅNLQJꢀLVꢀVHWꢀWRꢀꢇꢀRUꢀꢂꢎ
RUꢀLIꢀWKHꢀHꢀSURPꢀLVꢀDEVHQWꢎꢀWKHꢀXQLWꢀZLOOꢀDOZD\VꢀSRZHUꢀXSꢀLQꢀ%*ꢀPRGH
DQGꢀLPPHGLDWHO\ꢀSHUIRUPꢀDꢀIXOOꢀꢅDOLEUDWLRQꢀDIWHUꢀVWDUWXSꢆ
7KHꢀVDPSOHꢀDQGꢀKROGꢀꢅDQꢀEHꢀPDGHꢀRIꢀDꢀꢃꢍ+&ꢍꢇꢏꢏꢀW\SHꢀVZLWꢅKꢀDQG
DꢀꢁQ)ꢀꢅHUDPLꢅꢀꢅDSDꢅLWRUꢎꢀIROORZHGꢀE\ꢀDꢀ&026ꢀEXIIHUꢀDPSOLILHUꢆꢀ
0RGHꢀ PDQLSXODWLRQꢀ RYHUꢀ WKHꢀ 8$57ꢀ SRUWꢂꢀ 7KHꢀ %*ꢎꢀ 2%ꢕꢎꢀ DQG
%*ꢈ2%ꢕꢀ PRGHVꢀ ꢅDQꢀ EHꢀ PRGLILHGꢀ DWꢀ ZLOOꢀ YLDꢀ VHULDOꢀ ꢋ8$57-
ꢅRPPDQGVꢆꢀ $ꢀ VHULDOꢀ ꢅRPPDQGꢀ RSHUDWHVꢀ H[DꢅWO\ꢀ OLNHꢀ Dꢀ SRUWꢀ SLQ
DVVHUWLRQꢎꢀZLWKꢀWKHꢀH[ꢅHSWLRQꢀWKDWꢀDꢀꢓORQJꢓꢀDVVHUWLRQꢀLVꢀUHSODꢅHGꢀE\ꢀD
ꢅDSLWDOꢀOHWWHUꢀꢅRPPDQGꢆꢀ)RUꢀH[DPSOHꢎꢀ7RꢀDVVHUWꢀDꢀ%*ꢀꢅRPPDQGꢎꢀWKH
ORZHUꢅDVHꢀ OHWWHUꢀ ꢓEꢓꢀ LVꢀ VHQWꢀ WRꢀ WKHꢀ GHYLꢅHꢆꢀ 7Rꢀ DVVHUWꢀ Dꢀ %*ꢀ RYHUULGH
ꢅRPPDQGꢎꢀWKHꢀOHWWHUꢀꢓ%ꢓꢀLVꢀVHQWꢆꢀ7KHꢀ2%ꢕꢀꢅRPPDQGꢀLVꢀDꢅꢅRPSOLVKHG
YLDꢀ WKHꢀ OHWWHUVꢀ ꢓRꢓꢀ DQGꢀ ꢓ2ꢓꢆꢀ 5HIHUꢀ WRꢀ 6HꢅWLRQꢀ ꢍꢀ DQGꢀ 7DEOHꢀ ꢍꢄꢁꢀ IRU
GHWDLOVꢆ
:KHQꢀXVLQJꢀDꢀ6ꢈ+ꢀꢅLUꢅXLWꢀWRꢀREWDLQꢀDQꢀDQDORJꢀRXWSXWꢎꢀDYRLGꢀXVLQJꢀD
TXDGꢀRSDPSꢀVKDUHGꢀ DOVRꢀDVꢀWKHꢀPDLQꢀJDLQꢀ DPSOLILHUꢎꢀLQVWHDGꢀRIꢀWZR
VHSDUDWHꢀSDꢅNDJHVꢆꢀ7KHꢀVOHZꢀUDWHꢀDQGꢀORDGLQJꢀRIꢀWKHꢀ6ꢈ+ꢀEXIIHUꢀꢅDQ
SURGXꢅHꢀPDMRUꢀGLVWXUEDQꢅHVꢀLQꢀRWKHUꢀRSDPSVꢀRQꢀWKHꢀVDPHꢀGLHꢆ
7KHꢀ603ꢀOLQHꢀVKRXOGꢀQHYHUꢀEHꢀURXWHGꢀQHDUꢀWKHꢀ&VꢀVDPSOHꢀꢅDSꢀRUꢀWKH
DPSOLILHUꢀ RSDPSꢀ ꢅKDLQꢎꢀ DVꢀ WKLVꢀ SXOVHꢀ ꢅDQꢀ HDVLO\ꢀ VXSHULPSRVHꢀ D
VHYHUHꢀWUDQVLHQWꢀRQꢀWKHꢀVLJQDOꢀDWꢀWKHꢀH[DꢅWꢀPRPHQWꢀZKHUHꢀLWꢀVKRXOG
EHꢀVWDEOHꢆ
ꢇꢄꢃꢋꢄꢃꢀ:KHQꢀWRꢀ8VHꢀ(DꢆKꢀ0RGH
0RGHꢀVHOHꢅWLRQꢀGHSHQGVꢀRQꢀWKHꢀVHQVLQJꢀHIIHꢅWꢀGHVLUHGꢆ
ꢅꢁꢀꢆꢂꢄꢂ6(1625ꢂ5(62/87,21
7KHꢀ VHQVRU¶Vꢀ RYHUDOOꢀ VHQVLWLYLW\ꢀ LVꢀ Dꢀ IXQꢅWLRQꢀ RIꢀ VHYHUDOꢀ IDꢅWRUVꢎ
LQꢅOXGLQJꢒ
%*ꢂꢀ%*ꢀPRGHꢀLVꢀGHVLJQHGꢀWRꢀDOORZꢀDGYDQꢅHGꢀSURꢅHVVLQJꢀIXQꢅWLRQV
OLNHꢀ ³SUR[ꢀ WUDS´ꢀ ZKLOHꢀ DOVRꢀ SHUPLWWLQJꢀ GULIWꢀ ꢅRPSHQVDWLRQꢆꢀ %*ꢀ RQO\
UHTXLUHVꢀDꢀVLQJOHꢀꢅRPPDQGꢀWRꢀꢅDOLEUDWHꢀWRꢀWKHꢀEDꢅNJURXQGꢀOHYHOꢎꢀEXW
WKHꢀ WKUHVKROGꢀ OHYHOꢀ PXVWꢀ EHꢀ VHWꢀ YLDꢀ WKHꢀ HꢀSURPꢀ DQGꢀ ꢅDQQRWꢀ EH
µOHDUQHG¶ꢆꢀ%*ꢀZLOOꢀDOVRꢀSHUPLWꢀPD[LPL]HGꢀVHQVLWLYLW\ꢀZLWKꢀEDꢅNJURXQG
UHIHUHQꢅHꢀ GULIWꢀ WUDꢅNLQJꢀ DWꢀ DOOꢀ WLPHVꢆꢀ ,Wꢀ ZLOOꢀ DOVRꢀ SHUPLWꢀ µPRWLRQ¶
GHWHꢅWLRQꢀ SURꢅHVVLQJꢎꢀ ZKHUHꢀ PRWLRQꢀ LQꢀ HLWKHUꢀ GLUHꢅWLRQꢀ ZLOOꢀ ꢅDXVHꢀ D
GHWHꢅWLRQꢆꢀ2%ꢕꢀDQGꢀ%*ꢈ2%ꢕꢀꢅDQQRWꢀSURYLGHꢀWKHVHꢀIXQꢅWLRQVꢆ
ꢁꢆ 7RWDOꢀVDPSOHUꢀꢅDSDꢅLWDQꢅHꢎꢀ&Vꢀꢗꢀꢋ&]ꢁꢀꢆꢆꢆꢀ&]ꢍ-ꢀ ꢀ&7
ꢉꢆ %XUVWꢀOHQJWKꢎꢀ1
ꢑꢆ 7RWDOꢀDPSOLILHUꢀJDLQꢎꢀ$Y
ꢍꢆ $'&ꢀUHVROXWLRQꢎꢀELWVꢎꢀQ
ꢐꢆ 3RZHUꢀVXSSO\ꢀYROWDJHꢎꢀ9V
'LIIHUHQWLDOꢀ JDLQꢀ DWꢀ WKHꢀ RXWSXWꢀ RIꢀ WKHꢀ RSHUDWLRQDOꢀ DPSOLILHUꢀ LV
GHWHUPLQHGꢀE\ꢒ
2%-ꢂꢀ 8VHꢀ IRUꢀ GHWHꢅWLQJꢀ REMHꢅWVꢀ WKDWꢀ JHQHUDWHꢀ ODUJHꢀ VLJQDOVꢎꢀ ZKHUH
OLWWOHꢀSURꢅHVVLQJꢀILQHVVHꢀLVꢀUHTXLUHGꢆꢀ(YRNLQJꢀ2%ꢕꢀZLOOꢀWULJJHUꢀDꢀ³OHDUQ
E\ꢀ H[DPSOH´ꢀ DQGꢀ VHWꢀ WKHꢀ WKUHVKROGꢀ DXWRPDWLꢅDOO\ꢎꢀ DQGꢀ VWRUHꢀ WKDW
VHWWLQJꢀLQWRꢀWKHꢀHꢀSURPꢀLIꢀSUHVHQWꢆꢀ,IꢀQRꢀHꢀSURPꢀLVꢀSUHVHQWꢎꢀWKLVꢀPRGH
PXVWꢀ EHꢀ HQWHUHGꢀ DQGꢀ UHꢅDOLEUDWHGꢀ DIWHUꢀ HDꢅKꢀ SRZHUꢀ XSꢀ E\ꢀ HYRNLQJ
2%ꢕꢆꢀ7KLVꢀLVꢀDꢀVLPSOHꢀIL[HGꢀWKUHVKROGꢀSRLQWꢀZLWKRXWꢀNQRZOHGJHꢀRIꢀWKH
EDꢅNJURXQGꢀUHIHUHQꢅHꢀOHYHOꢆ
1 9V $9
>ꢉ@
ꢀ
ꢀꢀꢀ^YROWVꢀꢈꢀ&[`
&
7
7KHꢀ$'&ꢀUHVROXWLRQꢀLVꢀGHILQHGꢀLQꢀWHUPVꢀRIꢀYROWVꢀSHUꢀOHYHOꢎꢀUHVXOWLQJꢀLQ
WKHꢀIROORZLQJꢀRYHUDOOꢀVHQVLWLYLW\ꢀHTXDWLRQꢒ
$'& UHVROXWLRQ
GLIIHUHQWLDO JDLQ
>ꢑ@
6HQVLWLYLW\ꢀ ꢀ
ꢀ
ꢊ
QUANTUM [ QUANTUM RESEARCH GROUP ]
