=ꢀꢁꢁꢀꢂ
9ꢃꢁꢁ%,6ꢄ'DWDꢄ3XPSꢄZLWKꢄ,QWHJUDWHGꢄ$)(
ꢉꢀ
7DEOHꢄꢁꢀꢃ0RGHPꢄ'DWDꢄ3XPSꢄ:RUGꢄ'HILQLWLRQV ꢄꢅ&RQWLQXHGꢆ
5HJLVWHUꢄꢓꢄ$GGUHVVꢄ
ꢅKH[ꢆ
'HIDXOWꢄ
9DOXH
)XQFWLRQꢄDQGꢄ([SODQDWLRQ
06WDWXVꢆꢆꢆꢆꢆꢆꢆꢆꢆꢆꢆꢆꢆꢆꢆꢆꢆꢀꢈ) ꢀ+
0RGHPꢆ&RQWUROꢆDQGꢆ6WDWXV
Eꢈꢈ 5(75$,1ꢆꢐ)RUFHꢆDꢆ5HWUDLQꢋꢆ9ꢇꢅꢅELVꢑ
:KHQꢆVHWꢌꢆWKLVꢆELWꢆIRUFHVꢆDꢆUHWUDLQꢆLIꢆWKHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆKDVꢆDꢆ
9ꢇꢅꢅELVꢆFRQQHFWLRQꢇꢆ7KHꢆ&'(7ꢆꢐ5HJLVWHUꢆꢎꢆELWꢆꢈꢑꢆELWꢆLVꢆVHWꢆWRꢆꢀꢆ
ZKHQꢆWKHꢆUHWUDLQꢆEHJLQVꢇꢆ7KHꢆ&'(7ꢆELWꢆLVꢆVHWꢆWRꢆꢈꢆZKHQꢆWKHꢆ
UHWUDLQꢆLVꢆFRPSOHWHꢇꢆ7KHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆVHWVꢆ5(75$,1ꢆWRꢆꢀꢆZKHQꢆ
WKHꢆUHWUDLQꢆSURFHGXUHꢆEHJLQVꢆDQGꢆZKHQꢆWKHꢆKRVWꢆVHWVꢆ&RQILJꢆ
UHJLVWHUꢌꢆELWVꢆꢀ±ꢄꢆꢐ02'(ꢑꢆWRꢆDQ\ꢆGDWDꢆPRGHꢇ
Eꢅ 2))+22Bꢆꢐ(QDEOHꢆ2IIꢃ+RRNꢆ5HOD\ꢑ
7KHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆVHWVꢆWKHꢆ2+ꢆVLJQDOꢆWRꢆWKHꢆLQYHUWHGꢆYDOXHꢆRIꢆWKLVꢆ
ELWꢇꢆ)RUꢆH[DPSOHꢌꢆZKHQꢆ2))+22BꢆLVꢆꢈꢌꢆWKHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆVHWVꢆ
2+ꢆ/RZꢇꢆ:KHQꢆ2+ꢆLVꢆ/RZꢌꢆWKHꢆRIIꢃKRRNꢆUHOD\ꢆFORVHVꢆIRUꢆWKHꢆ
VLJQDOꢆIURPꢆWKHꢆWHOHSKRQHꢆOLQHꢆWRꢆEHꢆSUHVHQWHGꢆWRꢆWKHꢆGDWDꢆ
SXPSꢇ
7KHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆVHWVꢆ2))+22BꢆWRꢆꢈꢆZKHQꢆWKHꢆKRVWꢆVHWVꢆ
&RQILJꢆUHJLVWHUꢌꢆELWVꢆꢀ±ꢄꢆꢐ02'(ꢑꢆWRꢆꢂꢆꢐGLDOꢑꢌꢆRUꢆWRꢆDQ\ꢆGDWDꢆ
PRGHꢇꢆ7KHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆVHWVꢆ2))+22BꢆWRꢆꢀꢆDWꢆDQ\ꢆUHVHWꢇ
0RGLI\ꢆ2))+22BꢆRQO\ꢆZKHQꢆ&RQILJꢆUHJLVWHUꢌꢆELWVꢆꢀ±ꢄꢆ
ꢐ02'(ꢑꢆLVꢆVHWꢆWRꢆꢀꢆꢐ67$1'%<ꢑꢆWRꢆDYRLGꢆLQWHUIHUHQFHꢆZLWKꢆWKHꢆ
GDWDꢆSXPS¶VꢆXVHꢆRIꢆWKLVꢆELWꢇ
(40ꢆ0D[7KUHVKꢆꢆꢆꢀꢈ)ꢄ ꢍꢀꢀ+
(40ꢆ0D[LPXPꢆ7KUHVKROG
7KHꢆXSSHUꢆDFFHSWDEOHꢆOLPLWꢆIRUꢆWKHꢆ(\Hꢆ4XDOLW\ꢆ0RQLWRUꢆꢐ(40ꢑꢇꢆꢆ
'XULQJꢆ9ꢇꢅꢅꢌꢆ9ꢇꢅꢅELVꢆRUꢆ%HOOꢆꢅꢈꢅ$ꢆGDWDꢆPRGHꢌꢆWKHꢆ(40OHYꢆH[FHHGVꢆ
(400D[7KUHVKꢌꢆDQGꢆWKHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆVHWVꢆ'SFWUOꢌꢆELWꢆꢍꢆꢐ(4(ꢑꢆWRꢆꢈꢇꢆ
7KHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆVHWVꢆWKLVꢆORFDWLRQꢆWRꢆLWVꢆGHIDXOWꢆYDOXHꢆDWꢆDQ\ꢆUHVHWꢇꢆꢆ
&KDQJHVꢆLQꢆYDOXHꢆWDNHꢆHIIHFWꢆDWꢆWKHꢆHQGꢆRIꢆWKHꢆQH[WꢆEDXGꢆSHULRGꢇ
5/6'2II7KUHVKꢆꢆꢆꢀꢈ)ꢎ ±ꢍꢊꢆG%P 5HFHLYHGꢆ/LQHꢆ6LJQDOꢆ'HWHFWꢆ2))ꢆ7KUHVKROG
5/6'2Q7KUHVKꢆꢆꢆꢆꢀꢈ)ꢍ ±ꢍꢂꢆG%P 5HFHLYHGꢆ/LQHꢆ6LJQDOꢆ'HWHFWꢆ21ꢆ7KUHVKROG
7KLVꢆUHJLVWHUꢆUHSUHVHQWVꢆWKHꢆXSSHUꢆDQGꢆORZHUꢆWKUHVKROGVꢆRIꢆWKHꢆ
UHFHLYHGꢆWHOHSKRQHꢆOLQHꢆHQHUJ\ꢇꢆꢆ,Iꢆ5HJꢎꢌꢆELWꢆꢈꢆꢐ&'(7ꢑꢆWRꢆꢈꢌꢆDQGꢆWKHꢆ
WHOHSKRQHꢆOLQHꢆHQHUJ\ꢆIDOOVꢆEHORZꢆ5/6'2II7KUHVKꢌꢆWKHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆ
VHWVꢆ5HJꢎꢌꢆELWꢆꢈꢆꢐ&'(7ꢑꢆWRꢆꢀꢇꢆꢆ,Iꢆ5HJꢎꢌꢆELWꢆꢈꢆꢐ&'(7ꢑꢆLVꢆꢈꢆDQGꢆWKHꢆ
WHOHSKRQHꢆOLQHꢆHQHUJ\ꢆULVHVꢆDERYHꢆ5/6'2Q7KUHVKꢆꢆWKHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆ
VHWVꢆ5HJꢎꢌꢆELWꢆꢈꢆꢐ&'(7ꢑꢆWRꢆꢈꢇꢆꢆ7KHVHꢆWKUHVKROGVꢆVWDELOL]Hꢆ5HJꢎꢌꢆELWꢆꢈꢆ
ꢐ&'(7ꢑꢆE\ꢆK\VWHUHVLVꢆZKHQꢆ5/6'2II7KUHVKꢆLVꢆVHWꢆWRꢆDꢆORZHUꢆYDOXHꢆ
WKDQꢆ5/6'2Q7KUHVKꢇꢆꢆ8VHꢆWKHꢆIROORZLQJꢆIRUPXODꢆZKHQꢆWKUHVKꢆLVꢆ
VSHFLILHGꢆLQꢆG%PꢆDQGꢆLVꢆOHVVꢆRUꢆHTXDOꢆWRꢆꢀꢋꢆ
RꢁS8gx ꢔ ꢄꢂ(q) ꢃꢂꢂꢋ(ꢎꢃꢊꢉꢊ)
7KHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆVHWVꢆWKLVꢆORFDWLRQꢆWRꢆLWVꢆGHIDXOWꢆYDOXHꢆDWꢆDQ\ꢆUHVHWꢇꢆ
&KDQJHVꢆLQꢆYDOXHꢆWDNHꢆHIIHFWꢆDIWHUꢆWKHꢆQH[WꢆEDXGꢆSHULRGꢇ
36ꢀꢀꢀꢁꢀꢂꢃꢀꢄꢀꢅ