=ꢀꢁꢁꢀꢂ
9ꢃꢁꢁ%,6ꢄ'DWDꢄ3XPSꢄZLWKꢄ,QWHJUDWHGꢄ$)(
ꢁꢋ
$KV
ꢍ
ꢎ
ꢂ
ꢊ
ꢉ
ꢈ
ꢂ
ꢃ
ꢄ
ꢂ
ꢁꢁꢁꢂ
ꢁꢁꢂ
ꢁꢁꢂ
ꢁ6'0&
4:'44
'1(
7DEOHꢄꢂꢎꢃ5(*ꢍꢇꢄ+'/&ꢄ5HJLVWHU
6<0%2/ 326,7,21
1$0(ꢄ$1'ꢄ'(6&5,37,21
(2)
5(*ꢆꢉꢌꢆELWꢆꢀ
5HFHLYHꢆ(QGꢆRIꢆ)UDPHꢀꢆ7KHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆVHWVꢆ(2)ꢆWRꢆꢈꢆZKHQꢆDQꢆ+'/&ꢆIUDPHꢆKDVꢆ
EHHQꢆFRPSOHWHO\ꢆUHFHLYHGꢆꢐWKDWꢆLVꢌꢆZKHQꢆIUDPHꢆGDWDꢆKDVꢆEHHQꢆUHFHLYHGꢆDQGꢆDꢆ
FORVLQJꢆ+'/&ꢆIODJꢆRUꢆ+'/&ꢆ$ERUWꢆFRQGLWLRQꢆLVꢆUHFHLYHGꢑꢇꢆꢆ,IꢆWKHꢆIUDPHꢆZDVꢆ
FRUUHFWO\ꢆUHFHLYHGꢌꢆWKHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆDOVRꢆVHWVꢆ5HJꢎꢌꢆELWꢆꢈꢆꢐ5;(5525ꢑꢆWRꢆꢀꢌꢆ5HJꢎꢌꢆ
ELWꢆELWꢆꢄꢆꢐ5;,ꢑꢆWRꢆꢈꢌꢆDQGꢆ'$7$3ꢆWRꢆꢉ(+ꢇꢆꢆ6HHꢆ5HJꢉꢌꢆELWꢆꢈꢆꢐ5;(5525ꢑꢆIRUꢆDꢆ
GHVFULSWLRQꢆRIꢆ&5&ꢆHUURUVꢆDQGꢆ+'/&ꢆ$ERUWVꢇꢆ(2)ꢆUHIOHFWVꢆZKHWKHUꢆWKHꢆFXUUHQWꢆ
UHJLVWHUꢆ'$7$3ꢆYDOXHꢆLQGLFDWHVꢆWKHꢆHQGꢆRIꢆUHFHLSWꢆRIꢆDQꢆ+'/&ꢆIUDPHꢇꢆꢆ:KHQꢆWKHꢆ
ILUVWꢆGDWDꢆE\WHꢆRIꢆWKHꢆQH[Wꢆ+'/&ꢆIUDPHꢆLVꢆUHFHLYHGꢌꢆRUꢆLIꢆDQꢆ+'/&ꢆ$%257ꢆ
FRQGLWLRQꢆLVꢆUHFHLYHGꢆZKHQꢆQRꢆ+'/&ꢆIUDPHꢆGDWDꢆZDVꢆUHFHLYHGꢌꢆWKHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆ
VHWVꢆ(2)ꢆWRꢆꢀꢇꢆꢆ7KLVꢆFRQGLWLRQꢆPD\ꢆRFFXUꢆRQO\ꢆꢊꢆELWꢆWLPHVꢆDIWHUꢆWKHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆ
VHWVꢆ(2)ꢆWRꢆꢈꢇ
5;(55
5(*ꢆꢉꢌꢆELWꢆꢈ
5(*ꢆꢉꢌꢆELWꢆꢅ
5HFHLYHꢆ(UURUꢓꢆ,IꢆDQꢆ+'/&ꢆIUDPHꢆFRQWDLQVꢆDꢆ&5&ꢆHUURUꢌꢆRUꢆDQꢆ+'/&ꢆ$ERUWꢆ
FRQGLWLRQꢆLVꢆUHFHLYHGꢌꢆWKHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆVHWVꢆ5;(5525ꢆWRꢆꢈꢌꢆ5HJꢎꢌꢆELWꢆꢄꢆꢐ5;,ꢑꢆWRꢆꢈꢌꢆ
DQGꢆ'$7$3ꢆWRꢆWKHꢆYDOXHꢆRIꢆꢉ(+ꢆRUꢆ))+ꢇꢆꢆ,IꢆWKHꢆIUDPHꢆKDGꢆDꢆ&5&ꢆHUURUꢌꢆ'$7$3ꢆ
KDVꢆWKHꢆYDOXHꢆRIꢆꢉ(+ꢇꢆꢆ,IꢆDQꢆ+'/&ꢆ$ERUWꢆFRQGLWLRQꢆZDVꢆUHFHLYHGꢌꢆ'$7$3ꢆLVꢆ))+ꢇꢆ
5;(5525ꢆUHIOHFWVꢆZKHWKHUꢆWKHꢆFXUUHQWꢆUHJLVWHUꢆ'$7$3ꢆFRQWDLQVꢆDQꢆHUURUꢇꢆ:KHQꢆ
WKHꢆILUVWꢆGDWDꢆE\WHꢆRIꢆWKHꢆQH[Wꢆ+'/&ꢆIUDPHꢆLVꢆUHFHLYHGꢌꢆWKHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆVHWVꢆ
5;(5525ꢆWRꢆꢀꢇꢆ7KLVꢆFRQGLWLRQꢆPD\ꢆRFFXUꢆRQO\ꢆꢊꢆELWꢆWLPHVꢆDIWHUꢆWKHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆ
VHWꢆ5;(5525ꢆWRꢆꢈꢇ
7(1'
7UDQVPLWꢆ(QGꢆRIꢆ)UDPHꢇꢆꢆ7KHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆVHWVꢆ7(1'ꢆWRꢆꢈꢆZKHQꢆLWꢆFORVHVꢆDQꢆ+'/&ꢆ
IUDPHꢆWKDWꢆLVꢆWUDQVPLWWHGꢇꢆꢆ7KHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆVHWVꢆ7(1'ꢆWRꢆꢀꢆDIWHUꢆWUDQVPLWWLQJꢆWKHꢆ
&5&ꢆE\WHVꢌꢆZKHQꢆLWꢆVWDUWVꢆWUDQVPLWWLQJꢆWKHꢆFORVLQJꢆIODJꢆRIꢆWKHꢆ+'/&ꢆIUDPHꢇꢆꢆ7KHꢆ
GDWDꢆSXPSꢆFORVHVꢆDQꢆ+'/&ꢆIUDPHꢆZKHQꢆWKHꢆKRVWꢆGRHVꢆQRWꢆSURYLGHꢆGDWDꢆWRꢆ
WUDQVPLWꢆꢐVHHꢆ'$7$3ꢑꢆLQꢆWLPHꢆWRꢆEHꢆLQFOXGHGꢆLQꢆWKHꢆ+'/&ꢆIUDPHꢇ
ꢀ
5(*ꢆꢉꢌ
ELWVꢆꢂ±ꢉ
8QXVHGꢇꢆ6HWꢆWKHVHꢆELWVꢆWRꢆꢀꢇ
1RWHVꢋꢆ
ꢈꢇ $OOꢆWKHꢆELWVꢆLQꢆWKLVꢆUHJLVWHUꢆꢐ5(*ꢆꢉꢑꢆGHIDXOWꢆWRꢆꢀꢆDWꢆSRZHUꢆXSꢆRUꢆDIWHUꢆUHVHWꢇ
ꢅꢇ $OOꢆXQGHILQHGꢆELWVꢆRIꢆWKLVꢆUHJLVWHUꢆDUHꢆUHVHUYHGꢇꢆ7KHꢆKRVWꢆZULWHVꢆDꢆꢀꢆWRꢆDOOꢆUHVHUYHGꢆELWꢆSRVLWLRQVꢆZKHQꢆZULWLQJꢆWKLVꢆ
UHJLVWHUꢇꢆ7KHꢆKRVWꢆLJQRUHVꢆWKHꢆUHVHUYHGꢆELWVꢆZKHQꢆUHDGLQJꢆWKLVꢆUHJLVWHUꢇ
5HJꢍꢄ'DWDꢄ3XPSꢄ5HJLVWHUꢄꢍꢃꢄ7KHVHꢆELWVꢆUHSUHVHQWꢆWKHꢆVWDWHꢆRIꢆ+'/&ꢆIUDPHVꢆZKHQꢆ
WKHꢆGDWDꢆSXPSꢆLVꢆLQꢆWKHꢆ*&ꢀ%ꢆ(4#/+0)ꢆPRGHꢇꢆꢆ7KHVHꢆELWVꢆDUHꢆYDOLGꢆRQO\ꢆLIꢆ$7(%ꢒ
64ꢀꢓꢁELWꢆ7ꢁꢅ*&ꢀ%ꢆꢆLVꢆ1ꢇꢆꢆ7KHꢆKRVWꢆVKRXOGꢆUHIUDLQꢆIURPꢆZULWLQJꢆ5HJꢉꢆWRꢆDYRLGꢆFKDQJꢃ
36ꢀꢀꢀꢁꢀꢂꢃꢀꢄꢀꢅ